Thursday, November 19, 2026 A HERE CITY site · Visit HERECity.com

Specialty farm magazine
Daily ag business & commodities

Policy & Trade

Eight Senators and Grain Groups Urge Regulators to Block the Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern Merger

Eight senators, NGFA and corn growers urged the STB to reject the $71.5 billion UP-Norfolk Southern merger. Union Pacific says grain would move faster.

Timeline graphic of the Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger review: Nov. 18 comment deadline, Dec. 3 federal comments, May 28, 2027 final briefs and a vote expected in summer 2027, with a $71.5 billion deal value
Graphic: US Farm News, from DTN, Sen. Tammy Baldwin's office and NGFA information

Key takeaways

  • Eight senators from both parties, led by Wisconsin Democrat Tammy Baldwin and Kansas Republican Roger Marshall, asked the Surface Transportation Board on Nov. 18 to reject the Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger.
  • The National Grain and Feed Association and National Corn Growers Association filed opposition the same day, the board’s deadline for written public comments.
  • Union Pacific says grain would move with fewer handoffs, citing a Kansas-to-Pennsylvania wheat route it says would be about 36 hours faster.
  • Final briefs are due May 28, 2027, with a board vote expected within about 90 days after that, DTN reported.

Farm-state opposition to the proposed $71.5 billion Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern rail merger hardened on Wednesday, Nov. 18, as a bipartisan group of eight U.S. senators and two of the biggest grain-industry groups told federal regulators the deal should be turned down.

The senators’ letter to the Surface Transportation Board (STB), led by Sen. Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin and Sen. Roger Marshall of Kansas, argues that combining the two Class I railroads would cut shipper options and could raise freight costs for farmers and manufacturers. They were joined by Sens. Martin Heinrich, John Hoeven, Steve Daines, Amy Klobuchar, Tim Sheehy and Chuck Schumer, according to Baldwin’s office.

Why it matters to farmers

Rail moves a large share of the grain, fertilizer and feed ingredients that farm businesses buy and sell, and freight cost shows up directly in local basis. When a shipper has only one railroad to call, it has little bargaining power on rates or service. “The last thing our farmers need is higher shipping costs and more unreliable freight rail service,” Baldwin told Brownfield.

The deal would create a single railroad stretching across 43 states from coast to coast, DTN reported. Baldwin told Brownfield the combined company would handle close to half of U.S. rail traffic. The senators pointed out that only six Class I freight railroads remain, down from over 100 in the 1950s.

What the senators and farm groups said

  • Senators: They wrote that the railroads must show the merger will improve competition and deliver real benefits to shippers, “rather than simply promise greater efficiencies,” and said the companies have not met that test.
  • Rate comments: The letter cites a video, made public this month, of Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena telling a March shippers’ meeting he would probably raise rates 3% to 4% on opponents of the deal. Union Pacific has called the remark a joke and says it does not retaliate against customers, DTN reported. The senators asked the board to consider whether shippers can speak freely during the review.
  • NGFA: In new comments, the grain and feed group said losing a major Class I carrier would hurt competition and service for grain and feed shippers, and that no conditions could fully make up for it. NGFA President and CEO Mike Seyfert said the group does not believe the deal “meets the public-interest standard required for approval.” If the board leans toward approval anyway, NGFA listed protections it would want, including keeping competitive rail options and accountability for post-merger service failures.
  • NCGA: The corn growers’ nine pages of comments flagged that up to $20 billion of borrowing would pay for the deal, DTN reported, and argued that could push the merged company to lean on rates for existing traffic.

Brownfield noted that the American Farm Bureau Federation heads the opposition group known as the Stop the Rail Merger Coalition.

The case for the merger

Not every farm business is opposed. Ethanol producer POET is among supporters who say more direct routes would help farmers compete with imports, Brownfield said. Union Pacific has pointed to a filing by Ag Processing Inc., the Omaha-based farmer-owned cooperative, saying a combined network would open more East Coast export channels, according to DTN.

The railroad’s core argument is fewer handoffs. Union Pacific senior vice president Jason Hess said a Kansas wheat shipment headed to Pennsylvania now changes railroads in Kansas City, and that a single-line move would cut transit time by an estimated 36 hours, DTN reported.

What to watch

  • Dec. 3: Comments are due from the Justice Department and Transportation Department, according to DTN.
  • May 28, 2027: Final briefs to the STB after responses and rebuttals.
  • Summer 2027: A board decision, expected within about 90 days of final briefs.

For grain shippers and elevators, the outcome will shape freight options for years. Pair this with our look at how a shrinking barge fleet could affect grain basis, and follow the rest of our policy and trade coverage.

Get the Daily Ag Business Briefing

Markets, policy and farm business in one free email each weekday.

HERE CITY map pin

Part of the HERE CITY network

US Farm News is the national farm and ag-business desk of HERE CITY, a network of local news sites across America. Find your local HERE site at HERECity.com.

Explore HERECity.com